NC State University

ANT 431/595A: TOURISM, CULTURE AND ANTHROPOLOGY

Department of Sociology & Anthropology

Fall Semester 2008 Instructor: Tim Wallace
Office: 220 1911 Bldg. Box 8107, NCSU, Raleigh, NC 27695
Email address: tmwallace@mindspring.com 919-515-3180 (o); 919-815-6388 (cell)
http://www4.ncsu.edu/~twallace Office Hours: WF1:30-3:00, MWF4:30-5
Secretary: Bruce Cheek wbcheek2@sa.ncsu.edu; 919-515-2491

* Best to call to make an appointment to be sure we don't miss each other

Introduction to the Course

Tourism is a social, cultural, political and economic phenomenon. The impacts of tourism are enormous not only for whole countries, but also for small communities and wilderness areas. In this course we will take a broad approach to understanding the impact of tourism on the society, culture, economy and environment of human, esp. rural communities, around the world. We will rely heavily on anthropological concepts and methods, but will draw upon the contributions by scholars from many other disciplines. It is a multidisciplinary field, because (1) it is of interest to researchers and practitioners from many different fields, (2) the data gathered by researchers in one field are used by those in another and (3) people from both applied and theoretical perspectives find it to be interesting to study. Furthermore, and perhaps, more important, the tourism industry is one of the largest and most dynamic of any in the world. The goal of this course is to give students an understanding of tourist culture and its effect on the hosts and the environment. In this course, students study the impacts of tourism development on the culture, society, local economy and the environment of the local communities in international and domestic settings.

The anthropology of tourism is a relatively new topical area within cultural anthropology and has both theoretical and applied directions. Initially, anthropologists studied only the effects of tourism on host culture. Today there is a growing body of research that also investigates the interaction between hosts and guests in terms of social and environmental impacts. It is one of those fields that deals heavily with issues of culture change. Students will become familiar with both perspectives through study, discussion and fieldwork.

All of us in this class have either been tourists, seen tourists in action, or at least held strong opinions about tourists. Because we've all somehow been touched by tourism, our collective experiences and perceptions on the subject should make for some lively discussions and debate. All of us will be responsible for the learning that takes place in this course. As instructor, I have two key roles. One is to build a scaffolding for the class, selecting the readings and themes we will examine throughout the semester. The second is to facilitate creative and interesting discussions that will allow us to hear from each other. Your key contribution as a participant is to explore the readings carefully and come to class prepared for critical discussion. I will begin most classes with a lecture, and then encourage each of you to participate with your own perspectives, questions and analyses. If you prefer passive listening, this class is not for you!

As a part of the course students should participate in two or three field trips to tourism-dependent communities in North Carolina. The field trips are designed to assist students better understand the key issues discussed in the course and learn how anthropologists study tourism. Students who participate in the field trips will have to arrange their own transportation, pay for any food or lodging costs that might be involved, and assume any risks involved in traveling to the destinations. This course will primarily be a seminar type course, so it is important that you keep up with the readings and be prepared for discussion.

Course Objectives

By the end of the course the student will be able to:

1. explain the meanings and functions of tourism and travel in contemporary cultures and societies;

2. identify the key authors and theoretical perspectives in the anthropology of tourism, as well as the interrelationships between hosts and guests;

3. outline the positive and negative effects of tourism upon the socio-cultural, economic and physical environments with actual case studies;

4. interpret the type of cultural changes that result from tourism development in traditional communities,

5. explain how travel and tourism both reinforces and challenges one’s own cultural identity by encounters with alterity.

6. explain the role and function of international forces in ideological control in the hegemonic discourse of tourism; and,

7. outline the basic research techniques anthropologists use to study tourism.

Class Format and Philosophy

All of us in this class have either been tourists, seen tourists in action, or at least held strong opinions about tourists. Because we've all somehow been touched by tourism, our collective experiences and perceptions on the subject should make for some lively discussions and debate. All of us will be responsible for the learning that takes place in this course. As instructor, I have two key roles. One is to build a scaffolding for the class, selecting the readings and themes we will examine throughout the semester. The second is to facilitate creative and interesting discussions that will allow us to hear from each other. Your key contributions as a participant is to explore the readings carefully and come to class prepared for critical discussion. I will begin most classes with a lecture, and then encourage each of you to participate with your own perspectives, questions and analyses. If you prefer passive listening, this class is not for you!

Textbooks available in the NCSU Bookstores:

There are two readers and one book available in the bookstore.  In addition, there are two other books, one is a novel and the other is some of the articles in a journal issue.  Most of these are downloadable online, but are also available in a book form.  I have chosen a number of very interesting readings that will get you into the topic, that I think you will find very interesting.

Erve Chambers, Native Tours: The Anthropology of Travel and Tourism. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press, 2000.

Orvar Lofgren, On Holiday; A History of Vacationing. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1999. $19.95

Robert C. Davis and Garry R. Marvin, Venice: The Tourist Maze: A Cultural Critique of the Wolrd's Most Touristed City. Berkely, CA: U. of California Press, 2004.

Alex Garland, The Beach. New York: Riverhead Books, 1997. $11.95 (Can easily be found at used book stores both in the area and online.)

Extra Readings: Graduate students only:

Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger, eds. The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge, NY: Cambridge University Press, Canto edition, 1992 (orig. 1983). $17.99.

Richard Handler and Eric Gable, The New History in an Old Museum: Creating the Past at Colonial Williamsburg. Durham, NC: Duke U. Press, 1997.

Julia Harrison, Being a Tourist: Finding Meaning in Pleasure Travel. Vancouver: U. of British Columbia, 2003.

 

Course Requirements for Grade Evaluation

Undergraduate Course Requirements (ANT431)

Grading Scale: A+ = 97.0 -100; A=95.9-93.0; A-=92.9-90.0; B+= 89.9-87.0; B=86.9-83.0; B-82.9-80.0; C+=79.9-77.0; C=76.9-73.0; C-=72.9-70.0; D+=69.9-67.0; D=66.9-63.0; D-=62.9-60.0; F= <60.0

Requirements Explained (Undergraduate):

Attendance and Class Participation: Attendance is required. There is no penalty if you only miss two class dates, but you will lose ten points (on a 100 scale) from your overall grade for attendance for every unexcused absence thereafter. You should also be on time to class. If you are more than ten minutes late, you will be recorded as late. Two late notations equal one absence. Keep the instructor informed if you have an emergency during the semester that requires you to miss a class or be late. Class Participation: Classroom discussion is also very important. This means that you must come to class and answer questions when called upon and participate in group discussions and assignments. Your participation grade also will be determined in part by how well you have contributed to the dialogue in the classroom. You may also be called upon to participate in the presentation of an article summary or book chapter for the class.

Research Paper: This is a written (double-spaced, 15+ pages, 1" margins, 11" Arial font) research project which addresses some theme in the anthropology of tourism or ecotourism, selected from a list of topics to handed out. A paragraph about your topic is due on October.  The paper itself is due by the end of November.

Exams: The mid-term exam consists of a essay questions from class discussions and course readings. The final will be the same format, but emphasizing material from the final half of the course.

Field Trips. You are required to do two of the three field trips. You earn extra credit by doing all three.

Note: While you are strongly encouraged to make the three field trips, an alternate assignment could be designed for students who are financially or otherwise unable to make the trips. Students unable to go will be asked to do a similar investigation in another locale of their choosing, but with consultation from the professor.

Graduate Course Requirements (ANT595A)

Requirements Explained (Graduate):

Authenticity and tourism paper. This entails writing a ten page paper on the topic of authenticity, the invention of tradition and heritage tourism development, using Eric Hobsbawm’s edited anthology (Hobsbawm and Ranger 1983), and Handler and Gable's (1997) book on Colonial Williamsburg.  I will also recommend an additional article or two on authenticity. The 4 H’s (heritage, habitat, history and handicrafts) are often the starting point for community-based tourism development. Through the seminar and paper, students will come to understand the underlying theory of tourism, what is meant by the 4 H’s, how tourism works, what the consequences are for local people, the phenomenological response from tourists.  Guidelines for the paper will be distributed in class.

Critiques, class leadership and participation. Graduate students will attend and participate in a weekly, one-hour, discussion session about the course readings, to be scheduled at a convenient time. Students also will read and prepare for each seminar a brief, written critique of an one of the articles from that week's readings be prepared to discuss it in the seminar. Please use the form provided through this link.Each student will lead at least one discussion session during the seminar.Attendance and participation is expected. There is no formal penalty if you miss two class dates, but your participation grade could suffer by class absences. Attendance and participation in class discussion is expected. You should also be on time to class. If you are more than ten minutes late, you will be recorded as late. Keep the instructor informed if you have an emergency during the semester that requires you to miss a class or be late.

Research Paper This is a written (double-spaced, 10-15 pages, 1" margins, 11" Arial font) research project which addresses some theme in the anthropology of tourism or ecotourism, selected from a list of topics to handed out. A paragraph about your topic is due on October.  The paper itself is due by the end of November.  

Exams, (2) field trips. Same as undergraduate.

Course Outline

(Click here for some class notes)

Week 1. Introduction to the course, to cultural anthropology and to the anthropology of tourism

  • What the course is about
  • Week 2. Tourism in Anthropology and Defining Tourism

  • Why tourism is a fit subject for anthropology
  • tourism as culture change
  • Anthropologists and tourists
  • Defining tourism: marketing vs. anthropological perspectives
  • World Tourism Organization and the problem with statistics: international, national, internal and domestic tourism
  • Readings:

  • Wallace, ch. 1 - Introduction (This article is available through the NCSU libraries. Type <Anthrosource> when you search for a journal (online and search there for NAPA Bulletin No. 23)
  • Chambers, Preface and Ch. 1 (pp. vii-xii, 1-29)
  • D. Nash, Introduction from Anthropology of Tourism [ER]
  • Wallace, pp. 45-59 (Adams) (NAPA Bulletin No. 23)
  • Week 3 & 4.  Being a Tourist: Cultural, Psychological and Social Perspectives

  • Smith versus Cohen types
  • drifters and explorers
  • mass tourists, elite tourists, ecotourists, adventure tourists
  • allocentrics and psychocentrics (Plog)
  • the 4 S’s (sea, sand, surf, sex) vs. the 4 H’s (habitat, history, heritage, handcrafts)
  • backpackers and other Post-Fordist tourists
  • Trip to Old Salem 9/13/08
  • Readings - Week 3:

    Readings - Week 4:

    Week 5.   Brief history of travel and tourism

  • How old is tourism?
  • the "Grand Tour"
  • From picturesque to Niagara Falls
  • pilgrims and pilgrimages: Lourdes?
  • Phileas Fogg types versus the Robinson Crusoe types
  • Readings:

    Week 6. Brief History of Nature and Eco-tourism

  • Beach Tourism
  • Nature tourism
  • The idea of national parks as exclusion zones
  • The idea of ecotourism as a Western concept
  • Readings:

    Week 7.     Being a Tourist: Stories, Experience, Narratives, Identity and Gender

    Readings:

    Week 8.   Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Tourism Research

  • survey methods and sampling techniques
  • reliability, validity and accuracy
  • ethnographic methods
  • etic and emic methods
  • time allocation methods (diaries and time budgets)
  • problems in visual and written content analysis
  • Readings:

  • Rudi Hartmann, "Combining Field Research Methods..." 1988 [ER]
  • P. Sandiford, "The Role of Ethnographic Techniques in Tourism Planning" [ER]
  • Wallace, NAPA Bulletin 23, 135-150 (La Lone) (anthrosource)
  • NAPA Bulletin 23, 151-169 (Mason) (anthrosource)
  • Optional: D. Taplin, S. Shield and S. Lowe, "Rapid Ethnographic Assessment in Urban Parks: A Case Study of Independence National Park" [ER]
  • Optional: G. Gmelch, "Crossing Cultures: Student Travel and Personal Development" [ER]
  • Optional: G. Gmelch, Behind the Smile: The Working Lives of Caribbean Tourism, ch. 2 [ER]
  • Optional: C. Matthews, "The Location of Archaeology" in Ethnographic Archaeologies [ER]
  • Week 9.   Economic and Social Impacts of Tourism

  • economic advantages of tourism (multiplier effects, economic diversity, better balance of payments, etc.)
  • economic disadvantages of tourism (seasonality, leakages, opportunity costs, etc.)
  • Power dynamics of tourism
  • social change: the pros and cons
  • impact on local and indigenous people
  • collaborative approaches to cultural tourism development
  • Readings:

    Week 10.    Political Economy, Globalization and Sustainable Tourism

    Readings:

    Week 11.  Authenticity and Commoditization

  • Authenticity and Staged authenticity
  • Authenticity and identity
  • Commoditization
  • State control of local residents in tourist spaces
  • The Panopticon and the Tourist Gaze and post-tourists
  • Social structure among tourists and hosts
  • New Age tourism in a postmodern world
  • Readings:

  • D. Greenwood, "Culture by the Pound" [ER]
  • Davis and Marvin, pp. 55-132 (ch. 3-5)
  • Lofgren, pp. 72-106; 109-154
  • Chambers, ch. 4
  • Erik Cohen, Contemporary Tourism: Trends and Challenges Sustainable Authenticity or Contrived Post-Modernity? [ER]
  • Optional: Ernest Sternberg, "The Iconography of the Tourism Experience," Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.24, no. 4; 951-969, 1997 (can be found through library as an electronic journal)
  • Optional: B. Blount, Indigenous People and the Uses and Abuses of Ecotourism [ER]
  • Optional: Castañeda, Quetzil, "On the Correct Training of Indios in the Handicraft Market at Chichen Itza, Journal of Latin American Anthropology, 2(2), 1997: 106-132. (anthrosource)
  • Week 12. Cultural impacts of tourism:

  • sex and romance tourism
  • language of tourism in brochures and tour ads
  • changes in lifestyles
  • acculturation and choice
  • Commodification
  • Archaeology and tourism
  • modes of acceptance and cultural resistance to tourism-induced change
  • Readings:

    Week 13.   Exhibitions, Museums, Tours, Reshaping Images and Representation

  • Reshaping images, rewriting histories and staging tourism
  • Apparatus of tourism representation
  • The packaged tour
  • Heritage tourism
  • Ethnic and cultural tourism
  • The effect of images (representation) on tour development & interpretation
  • Identity and tourism construction
  • Indians and the gaming industry
  • Souvenirs, photos and stories
  • Readings:

  • Edward Bruner, "Tourism in Ghana" [ER]
  • Lofgren, pp. 155-209; 240-259
  • Davis and Marvin, pp. 133-180 (ch. 6-7)
  • Optional: Wallace, pp. 87-118 (Castañeda), NAPA Bulletin No. 23
  • Optional: de Uriarte, "Imagining the Nation with House Odds" [ER]
  • Optional: H. Tucker, "The Ideal Village: Interactions through Tourism in Central Anatolia" [ER]
  • Weeks 14-15. Environmental impacts of tourism: Tourism, Sustainability, Parks

  • Conservation models and ecotourism development
  • Participatory development in ecotourism planning
  • Community-based tourism
  • Globalization and power and the Third World
  • How well does nature tourism protect the environment?
  • The impact of Post-Fordist tourism in the Third World
  • Environmental NGO’s, e.g., The Nature Conservancy, WWF, Sierra Club
  • Industry and redefining sustainability
  • Readings:

    POTENTIAL TERM PAPER TOPICS

  • Sex Tourism
  • The beach as part of a construction of identity and place in tourism destinations
  • Redefining expatriates as residents in tourism settings
  • Museums, and assisting in tourism development
  • Art, Tourist Art and Tourism
  • Handcrafts, Artisans, Craft Specialization and tourism
  • Potters and tourists
  • The Concept of Nature, Parks and Wilderness and the development of tourism
  • How locals resist tourism and tourists
  • Movies and Romance tourism
  • the Anthropology of Backpackers
  • Tourism as a pilgrimage
  • White-water rafting and "risk tourism"
  • Tourism as seen through the eyes of indigenous/local people
  • Tourism and international ecopolitics: National parks, conservation and indigenous peoples
  • The role of dark tourism (holocaust tours, Jack the Ripper tours, morgue sightseeing)
  • Tourists and terrorists: Danger and tourism
  • OTHER IMPORTANT INFORMATION

    Exams and missed tests: The mid-term and final exams are essay. If you miss a test due to an excused absence, you will be given the opportunity to take a make-up test at a mutually convenient time. There will be no make-ups for unexcused absences.

    Incompletes: Incompletes will only be given if the student meets the university requirements outlined in the following document: http://www.ncsu.edu/policies/academic_affairs/pols_regs/REG205.00.13.php

    Academic Integrity Statement: Cheating will not be tolerated. Any form of cheating results in an automatic "F" for the test/assignment/homework with which it is connected. Violations of academic integrity may result in an F for the course. For a clear statement of NCSU’s Academic Integrity policy, please visit this website: http://www.ncsu.edu/policies/student_services/student_discipline/POL11.35.1.php

    Violations of the Student Honor Code will be reported to the appropriate person in your department/College (advisor, Dean, etc.). Everything turned in should be individual work. NCSU has a policy on academic integrity found in the Code of Student Conduct and you should consult it. Note that this policy includes an Honor Pledge. This means that on tests and other individual student assignments that the teacher expects that the student understands that she or he neither gave nor received unauthorized aid.

    Students with Disabilities:  Reasonable accommodations will be made for students with verifiable disabilities. In order to take advantage of available accommodations, students must register with Disabilities Services Office of Students located at 1900 Student Health Center, Campus Box 7509, 919-515-7653 (http://www.ncsu.edu/dso/). In accordance with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 ("Rehab Act"), the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), and state law, North Carolina State University (hereinafter NC State) is required to accommodate an otherwise qualified individual with a disability by making a reasonable modification in its services, programs, or activities. This regulation addresses the eligibility of students for academic accommodations in educational programs, services, and activities at NC State, as well as the provision of such accommodations to students with various types of disabilities. Students desiring special assistance because of any permanent or temporary disability may be eligible for these services. See: http://www.ncsu.edu/policies/academic_affairs/courses_undergrad/REG02.20.1.php or http://www.ncsu.edu/policies/academic_affairs/courses_undergrad/REG02.20.7.php.  Contact Disability Services Office at 513-7653, and consult the website: http://www.ncsu.edu/provost/offices/affirm_action/dss/.

     Anti-Discrimination Statement: The role of all employees and students is to create and maintain a supportive and harassment-free working environment for all members of the campus community. All faculty, staff and students are responsible for understanding and complying with harassment policies: these policies can be viewed at: http://www.ncsu.edu/equal_op.  Also, all faculty, staff and students are responsible for knowing where to obtain assistance for resolving concerns. Members of the campus community are encouraged and should feel free to seek assistance, information, and guidance from their department head, supervisor, the Office for Equal Opportunity (513-3148), Human Resources (515-4300) or the Office for Student Conduct (515-2963). All harassment of any person (either in the form of quid pro quo or creation of a hostile environment) based on race, color, religion, creed, sex, national origin, age, disability, veteran status or sexual orientation also is a violation of state, federal law and/or NC State University policy and will not be tolerated. Retaliation against any person who complains about discrimination is also prohibited. NC State‘s policies and regulations covering discrimination, harassment, and retaliation may be accessed at http://www.ncsu.edu/policies/campus_environ or http://ncsu.edu/equal_op. Any person who feels that he or she has been the subject of prohibited discrimination, harassment, or retaliation should contact the Office for Equal Opportunity (OEO) at 919-515-3148.